Mafia Round 2!

Round 2 of mafia has begun! Go here to see the rules:
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]

Player List: Lynched Killed by Mafia Removed
RyanCummings
Sko - Sheriff
Arkán Dreamwalker
Aftershocker
CD333 - Townie
Kaida - Tiebreaker
underseasie
Sammy14:)

There is a Godfather, two mafia, a doctor, a sheriff, 2 townies, and a tiebreaker.

Night has fallen. Mafia - send me your kill, Doctor - send me your save, and Sheriff - your investigation.

Can an admin please lock this thread until daybreak?

Ready and Rollin'

What is the story Sunny?

Okay, thanks to Eugene and Sammy for their help getting some things figured out, and to Aftershocker for his reminder about this, as I have a really busy day today, so I nearly forgot!

So here's what happened:

It had been a long day of hard work for her. And as darkness set in, Kaida hurried home for a quick meal before she went to bed. Sleep came easily to her tonight, and little did she know that she was the mafia's next victim. In the darkness of the night, she suddenly awoke as she felt a sharp blade at her throat. And within seconds, the Tiebreaker was no more.

It is now day. You may start your voting. You have 72 hours left, as of tomorrow.

:O No not Kaida! Not my dear sister!! I shall avenge her!!

We need to figure out who did this. Any ideas?

It was Sammy!! She would do something like this to Kaida!

I think it was probably RyanCummings. You saw how mafia-like he was in the snowball fight.

RyanHoots wrote:I think it was probably RyanCummings. You saw how mafia-like he was in the snowball fight.

That is so true! What so you guys have to say for yourselves?

I am not the mafia. I think it is either RyanHoots, or CD333. RyanHoots was awfully quick to shuffle the blame on to me, and for no real reason other than I was tactical in Snowball (which by the way, if that is a reason to kill off a townsperson, then almost everyone playing is the mafia). Plus, if I was mafia, I would probably kill RyanHoots (no offense) because he knows me in real life, and could easily tell if it was me.

The only reason I think it might be CD333 is because I don't know CD333 that well, and people who I don't know, but see online creep me out.

That is all I have to say in my defense.

Is there anybody else someone wants to accuse?

RyanCummings wrote:Plus, if I was mafia, I would probably kill RyanHoots (no offense) because he knows me in real life, and could easily tell if it was me.

Yep, it was him. He's being too defensive.

Can a person be too defensive?

Arkán Dreamwalker wrote:Can a person be too defensive?

It depends on how you look at it. I think RyanC is being uncharacteristically defensive, he doesn't usually act like this.

It could be you, Hoots. You're probably trying to pin it on Cummings or... :O probably both of you are the Mafia!!! :O

Haha, AS. If we were both mafia, it wouldn't make sense for me and RyanH to be killing each other.

I don't think I was being too defensive. If being defensive is a crime, then I guess I am guilty. But I will tell you this, the mafia always finds a few tiny fake faults of townspeople and exploits them repeatedly to try and get rid of as many townspeople as they can, which is why I think RyanH is the mafia. He is trying to kill me, and has no real reason that I am guilty. His first reason was that I was doing well in the snowball fight, and then when I said how crazy that is, he said I was being to defensive. I think it is pretty obvious that RyanH is the mafia.

Sorry if that was drawn out. I do speech and debate, so my answers are kind of complicated.

RyanCummings wrote:Sorry if that was drawn out. I do speech and debate, so my answers are kind of complicated.

I like the way you think. But, that doesn't change the fact that I'm against you in this debate, so I'm going to keep arguing. Of course, for all I know, Aftershocker's the mafia. Don't forget, guys, that most of the people playing the game have yet to show their heads. It's likely that the mafia are watching us fighting now, and rolling dice to decide who's next.

But right now, I have two suspects. Both of you have motive (the rules say you have to kill someone), and opportunity (all you have to do is PM the game directer to say who you want to kill).

Here's my reasoning.

The Mafia are smart. I don't doubt that. RyanC, you've been very verbal in this debate. In fact, you were being defensive when you were saying you weren't too defensive. The Mafia hide in the day, and strike at night. You heard me say I thought you were Mafia, and you came running to clear your name, but you haven't tried very much to give the blame to someone else. You just want people to put your name off the suspect list.

The townspeople have one defense: day time. And as a member of this town, I'm going to defend it with all I have, even if I don't have much. Sure, I admit I'm being way, way, too aggressive, but that only makes the game more interesting for me, and everyone else reading this. And if I live or die, I know it doesn't matter in real life.

How exactly are you going to defend the town?

But here is the thing, I truly think RyanH is the mafia. That is what I deduce from his posts. The mafia often draw the blame to people for no real reason, and have to make it sound somewhat reasonable in order to kill off the townspeople. If you look closely at RyanH's posts, he does not have valid reasons to kill me, or that I am the mafia. When I said I am not the mafia, he said I was defensive. Of course I am defensive. I want to stay alive and keep as many townspeople from dying as possible. If he kills me, then he has already gotten a townsperson. Plus, the mafia plant little seeds of doubt. RyanH said that I didn't ever give any other people to kill, I only defended myself. I actually gave RyanH and CD333 as my suspects.

However, the fact is, we need to kill someone. If RyanH isn't the mafia, then we should keep him around for a while because he is a good thinker. But not too long if it seems that he really is the mafia. I think for now, we should do CD333.

I'll go with CD333, as well. He hasn't posted, nor really said anything...come to think of it, I've never even met him.

All right lets go with CD333!

VOTE: CD333

Vote: CD333

So far...
CD333 - 3 (counting Rosy)

Give me one valid reason it's not RyanC, and I will vote for CD333.

Just to to let you all know, you have 48 hours left.

Two more days til we execute some one and the Mafia strikes again.